Home/Journal/Acne scars: which treatment works for which type of scar

Journal · Aesthetic Medicine

Acne scars: which treatment works for which type of scar

Brown marks, rolling, boxcar and ice-pick scars: how to tell which you have, which treatment suits each type, realistic results, and why brown skin needs a gentler plan.

By Dr. Hossam Mohammed
13 November 2026
6 min read
Dr. Hossam Mohammed at work in his clinic, Soleá Clinic Dubai
Dr. Hossam Mohammed at work in his clinic, Soleá Clinic Dubai

The acne has finally settled, but it left marks behind. Some are dips you can feel. Some are just colour. In daylight or under a bathroom light, they seem to be all you can see. You have read about lasers, peels, microneedling and filler, and you do not know which one is meant for you.

The honest answer is that it depends on the type of scar. Most people have more than one type, which is why a single treatment rarely fixes everything.

The short version

Acne leaves two kinds of marks: colour marks, which are flat, and true scars, which change the skin’s surface. Flat brown or red marks usually fade with time, sunscreen and gentle treatment. Dented scars come in different shapes, and each shape responds to something different. Active acne should be controlled before scar treatment starts.

First: is it a mark or a scar?

  • Brown marks. Flat patches left after a spot heals, very common in brown and olive skin. Doctors call this post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. It is colour, not a scar, and it usually fades over months.
  • Red or pink marks. Also flat, from small blood vessels after inflammation. They usually fade too.
  • True scars. These change the surface. You can see a shadow or feel a dip or a bump.

A quick test: stretch the skin gently between two fingers. If the mark disappears or softens, it is likely a rolling scar. If it is flat and only colour, it is a mark, not a scar.

The types of dented scars

  • Rolling scars. Wide, soft dips with sloping edges, which give the skin a wavy look. They are caused by bands under the skin that pull the surface down.
  • Boxcar scars. Round or oval dips with sharp edges, like small craters.
  • Ice-pick scars. Narrow, deep holes, as if the skin was pricked with a sharp tool.

Less often, acne leaves raised scars, especially on the chest, back and jawline. These need a different approach again.

Which treatment for which scar

  • Brown marks: daily sunscreen, creams that calm pigment, and sometimes gentle peels.
  • Rolling scars: releasing the bands under the skin with a fine needle, a technique called subcision, often followed by microneedling. Sometimes a small amount of filler helps lift a wide dip.
  • Boxcar scars: microneedling, radiofrequency microneedling or fractional laser, usually over several sessions.
  • Ice-pick scars: treated one by one with focused techniques. Treatments that go across the whole surface do not reach them well.
  • Raised scars: usually injections into the scar itself, and gentle settings to avoid making them worse.

Most people need a combination, planned over several months.

What results to expect

Treatment improves acne scars. It rarely makes them disappear completely. A realistic goal is skin that looks smoother and catches the light more evenly.

  • Sessions: usually three to four, four to six weeks apart, for microneedling or laser.
  • Recovery: redness for two to four days, then light flaking, for most microneedling treatments.
  • Timeline: new collagen keeps forming for three to six months after the last session, so the final result shows slowly.

If you have brown or olive skin

Darker skin can react to heat and irritation by making more pigment. This can leave new dark marks after treatment. The answer is not to avoid treatment. It is to prepare the skin for two to four weeks first, use gentler settings, and do more sessions instead of stronger ones. Microneedling is often a good choice for this reason.

When I say not yet

  • If your acne is still active. New spots mean new scars. We control the acne first.
  • If you took isotretinoin, an acne tablet, in the last six months, for most treatments.
  • If you form keloids, thick raised scars, for deeper treatments.
  • If you are pregnant, for most of these treatments.

How I do things

I look at your skin under side lighting, which shows dips that flat light hides. I sort the scars by type and mark which treatment suits each area. If you have active acne, we treat that first.

If some scars will not respond much to what I offer, I will tell you, so you can decide with the full picture.

Questions I get asked every week

Can acne scars be removed completely?

Usually not. Treatment can make them much less visible, but most scars improve rather than disappear.

How many sessions will I need?

Often three to four sessions of microneedling or laser, four to six weeks apart, sometimes with other treatments in between.

Do brown acne marks need laser?

Usually not. Flat brown marks often fade with sunscreen, creams and time. Gentle peels can help.

Can I treat scars while I still get spots?

It is better to control active acne first, so new scars are not forming while we treat the old ones.

Is microneedling safe for darker skin?

It is often well suited to darker skin because it does not rely on heat, but preparation and daily sunscreen are still important.

Please remember

This article is general information, not medical advice for you personally. Results vary between individuals, and every treatment needs a face-to-face consultation with a licensed doctor first, so we can talk about your health, your goals and the risks.

Read more on my skin resurfacing in Dubai page, or book a consultation.


Sources

  • Jacob CI, Dover JS, Kaminer MS. Acne scarring: a classification system and review of treatment options. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2001.
  • Fabbrocini G, et al. Acne scars: pathogenesis, classification and treatment. Dermatology Research and Practice, 2010.
  • Cohen BE, Elbuluk N. Microneedling in skin of color: a review of uses and efficacy. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2016.
  • Davis EC, Callender VD. Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation: a review of the epidemiology, clinical features, and treatment options in skin of color. Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology, 2010.

Considering treatment?

Consultations at Soleá Clinic, Dubai, are by appointment. We discuss whether a treatment is right for you before anything is booked.

Reserve a consultation